Response to LV's "CRITIQUE OF JOKING RELATIONS"
Hi, LV. I really liked the way that you structured the whole critique. At the beginning of it, you gave a very clear definition of how Radcliffe-Brown would describe the joking relationship, which helped to clarify the scope of the discussion. Regarding the content, I also found the Dogon men example interesting and representative, and a comparative example that I can think of would be the wife and mother-in-law relationship as well as husband and father-in-law relationship in Chinese culture. The idea of extended family and grandparent family is still prevalent in modern Chinese society, and according to the social norms, the married couples are supposed to keep a harmonic relationship with parents from both sides, especially for wives, which is also where this asymmetrical joking relationship more obviously exists.
The antagonism of this type of joking relationship partially comes from parents' possessiveness of their kids, but there is definitely more than that. Moms often keep a joking relationship with the son's wife, while being mostly friendly with the daughter's husband. Similarly, fathers only show their antagonism and hostility to the daughter's husband instead of the son's wife. This might be because the same gender (mother-in-law and wife, father-in-law and husband) holds the same gender role in one family structure, which more or less leads to an environment of competitiveness. A new wife can be seen as a threat to the mother-in-law sometimes because she has the potential to replace the other and become the hostess of this household.
And at the same time, for the new wife who just departs from her original family and enters a new social group, her social disjunction will certainly counter her conjunction and raise anxiety. In this case, the normally asymmetric joking relationship will become symmetric. The son's wife might express her anxiety and disjunction in a not so pleasant but rather hostile way. Therefore, throughout Chinese history until modern society, the relationship between mother-in-law and daughter-in-law has always been a huge issue of family relationships in an extended family structure, especially when it comes to grandparent families, where more conflict would happen over the nurturance and education of the youngest generation. In this case, we could surely see how joking relationships work to dismantle any possible power struggles, frustration from a lack of compatibility, and anxieties associated with joining a new social group.
By Fuyuan Zheng
Comments
Post a Comment