Response to Josh's "Social-Cultural Critique of Community Gardens"

 Hey Josh!

I think it's important you brought the concept of the community garden into the framework of food deserts. Gardening has been a key component of community sustenance since the birth of agriculture, and we can see many examples of ancient gardens preserved in archaeological record. There are utilitarian gardens preserved all across the ancient Middle East and Mediterranean which are somewhat allegorical for modern community gardens. They were used to provide sustenance or to sell produce and make a living for the gardener, and gardens owned by individuals would often end up being valued methods of sustenance for small communities  - especially in regions which were arid or lacked farmable land or sufficient water resources, as is the case across much of Egypt, the ancient Middle Eastern landscape, and even many areas of Greece and Rome (Carroll 2003).

Today, the cause of issues is different, but the result is the same. Instead of living in an actual desert (although this can also be true), people live in communities which are impoverished and with little access to healthy food. I like your use of Malinowski's hierarchy of needs to examine the cultural impact of these gardens: it places stress on the garden not just as food, but as a societal building block as well. In environments where a garden is cost-effective and the weather allows for at least a seasonal garden, I wonder how much nutrition can be gained from a community garden. I'm also prompted to think of the concept art I have seen for 'vertical gardens' or 'vertical forests': buildings in cities constructed to allow for economic plant growth, providing food and cleaning the air. I wonder how communities built in such a way could bolster protection against food deserts. If they became commonplace, could they be at least a partial solution to food deserts? Community gardens as they are certainly aid in the fight against malnutrition, and as you said they sometimes create cultural events and establish a culture of their own as is necessary for the maintenance of the garden. If these gardens were to be expanded to vertical gardens or otherwise, they could create entire new subcultures for those living in the garden-based community, ones more environmentally focused and self-sustaining. This also ties into the concept of gift-giving you talk about - if each gardener in the community is doing chores or somehow caring for the garden in a way that earns them a gift from the other gardeners, this would create a community tied together by the creation of sustenance. Each person who lives in the community would have their ties strengthened by participating in the garden. At the risk of sounding somewhat idealistic, I think you have a good concept for how community gardens impact the communities they're in, and their potential for sustaining and strengthening those communities.

By RJ Pratt


WORK CITED

Carroll, Maureen. Earthly Paradises: Ancient Gardens in History and Archaeology. United Kingdom: J. Paul Getty Museum, 2003.

Comments

Popular Posts