Response to Jarrett's Critique of Joking Relations

 BY: LISETTE VICTORIA SAN PEDRO

Nice job Jarrett,

I also critiqued Radcliffe-Brown’s Joking Relations and found similar weaknesses in his argument. First, I agree he, along with many other structural-functionalists minimized the influence of one’s agency on their relations with others in social and kin groups. Additionally, I believe his faults and others are largely a product of focusing on binaries. Although, binaries help individuals to classify and quickly understand society, I feel as though it is too simplistic of a framework to understand complex behavioral structures. Many times, behaviors or in grey areas of agency and structure which is reduced by binary thinking.

I completely agree with how you stated that his generalizations likely stem from too much fieldwork instead of theory. I also think, his case studies were somewhat homogenous in the sense they all had similar structures and I would have been interested to see how he analyzes the ideas of conjunction and disjunction in a culture that lacks this structure. I feel as though he would argue any society that does not follow the joking relations, build conjunction through his other three modes, such as intermarriage, exchange of goods and services, or blood brotherhood. In my analysis, I also noticed how influenced his ideas were by Durkheim’s mechanical and organic solidarity and I understood joking relations to be a form of mechanical solidarity because of the society’s homogenous culture less diversified work and kin groups. All in all, Radcliffe-Brown distinguished a specific, unique structure that can easily be written off as a bravado personality type, I just feel as though it is important to not generalize this structure as universal.


Comments

Popular Posts