Critique on Kroeber's On the Principle of Order in Civilization

By Hex Li


Indoctrinated by Boas, Kroeber chose an opposite road with the other Boas' students such as Benedict and Mead. According to his work On the Principle of Order in Civilization as Exemplified by Changes of Fashion, it’s clear that, believing in the concept of “superorganic”, he went against Boasian focus on individuals and turned back to theories of earlier thinker such as Durkheim and Freud who emphasized on the influence of society acting on individuals behavior. In terms of research method, while Boas promoted scientific and intensive ethnography data collection, Kroeber decided to take Durkheim’s approach--being very similar with Durkheim’s research method in his work on suicide--to use general collective data of evening dresses from fashion magazines, such as Bazar and Vogue, to reflect cultural pattern. 

From the perspective of his data collecting method, the fact that Vogue and Bazar back in the 19-20th centuries mainly recorded haute couture brands, which were less than15 brands at that time, and luxury designers had proved the limitation of the application of his theory (anybody interested in seeing a 1892 vogue can use this link: https://www.vogue.com/article/vogue-125-1892-2017-compare-and-contrast-now-and-then). Mainly targeting the audience above middle-class, it became even more difficult for having a representative conclusion of the entire society; in addition, distinguishing the cause of change in tailoring between the taste of higher social class or an idealistic driving force of society was tricky as well. 

The reason why I said it’s not convincing to summarize data from haute couture and luxury designers laid in the historical background that Kroeber didn’t touch upon; for example, in page 252, when Kroeber offered a graph of the variation of length of skirt, length of waist, and decolletage from 1845 to 1920, he simply discussed the recurring cycle of range of length of skirt without indicating the similarity or dissimilarity of the occurring social events/status behind. But what is haute couture? The French government had strictly regulated the standard of haute couture: 

(1)design made-to-order for private clients with one or more fittings; 

(2)have a workshop(atelier) in Paris that employs at least fifteen staff members full-time;

(3)have at least twenty full-time technical people in at least one workshop;

(4)present a collection of at least fifty original designs to the public every fashion season ;(so basically 100 designs a year with most of them hand-made)

…

From just a few standards, we can all observe that the cost of having a haute couture required a corresponding customer group with high social and economic status, which further proved that the data that Kroeber generated were not as representative as they seemed to be. Also, not seeing much influence of Boasian cultural relativism, the limitations of Kroeber's On the Principle of Order in Civilization as Exemplified by Changes of Fashion located in overgeneralization and cultural superiority, which are typical weaknesses of the earlier thinker’s theories. Believing that the default definition of fashion laid in European mainstream fashion itself revealed an ignorance towards the marginalized cultures and society such as those living in tribes.  

I have to say, it’s undeniable that culture and society influence individuals’ decisions and behavior; for example, brushing our hair before going out is a cultural pattern; although it won’t hurt us physically if we don’t brush it, the social norm required us to be clean affects us to do it everyday. However, when it comes to fashion, Kroeber made a wrong choice. Rising in price is a standard commercial behavior that some very luxury brands such as Hermés and Chanel have done; according to my interviewee whose parents are in the executive position of Chanel in the Pacific region, the reason why Chanel decided to rise its bag collection price to an additional 30% in 2020 was that Chanel wanted more elite customers and eliminated some of the middle-class customers so that its status of being a haute couture house would not be devalued by the middle-class customers and their VIP customers would feel more comfortable buying from the brand. In addition, among the themes and inspiration of the haute couture collections, there would not be any aggressive and activist themes that the ready-to-wear collection (those we, normal citizens can buy online or in-store) would have due to their targeted customer’s taste. It’s interesting to look at new-comers of the haute couture, descendants and friends who are recognized in the same social groups are usually the, because it’s a closed circle with rarely new blood. As a result, I argue that fashion, at least in Kroeber’s definition, is almost unchanged along the time and only the higher class is able to define the term “fashion”, because, as I mentioned above, fashion like haute couture historically has been designed and created from the need of those fewer individuals in higher social class who can not represent society as a whole.


Comments

Popular Posts