Critique of White's "Energy and the Evolution of Culture"

RUOHAN LI


In the “Energy and Evolution of Culture”, Leslie White lays out a model of cultural evolution to explain the formation of a complex society. White claims that “everything in the universe may be described in terms of energy”, therefore, energy is the basis of the cultural evolution in his argument. White first discusses that the purpose of culture is to serve the needs of men, and human needs include those that can be satisfied by drawing resources within the human organism (dancing, myth-making, companionship) and those that can be satisfied by extracting resources from the external world (food, tools). In this article, since White only considers variable factors, he pays more attention to the satisfaction of needs from the outside world, which focuses on the material and mechanical means of development. Then, White lays out the five factors needed to be considered in cultural situation and eventually concentrates on the relationship between three factors: amount of energy per capita per unit of time harnessed and put to work (E), technological means of its expenditure (T), and magnitude of product per unit of time (P). He formulates the relationship as E * T = P, and further generalizes the factor T as efficiency of the mechanical means that energy is expended (F), as E * F = P. This formula indicates a directly proportional relationship between E and P as well as F and P, which means the increase in either energy expenditure or efficiency of energy expenditure would lead to the increase in productivity. With this equation, White thus presents the law of cultural evolution as “culture develops when the amount of energy harnessed by man per capita per year is increased; or as the efficiency of the technological means of putting this energy to work is increased; or as both factors are simultaneously increased”. 


Since humans have the biological urge to live and strive, they always attempt to find better and more efficient means of surviving. Therefore, humans start to harness natural resources, domesticate animals and plants, and invent or improve tools. This motivation of having a more efficient and secure life, constant learning and development are the essence behind White’s model of history of culture. The earliest stage occurs as humans only use wind, fire, water and human power for living. The cultural development and maximum efficiency are limited due to the limitation of source of energy. Soon, the domestication of animals and plants or increased control over nature emerges and enables humans to produce more food to meet basic needs. With further development, animal and plant domestication evolved into agriculture and animal husbandry, which based on White, the basis of culture. With agriculture and animal husbandry, human’s control over nature is direct and immediate. Food production becomes more productive and creates surplus, thus leads to a large increase in human population. Since humans do not have to spend most of their time hunting and gathering food, occupational groups or job specialization emerge. Later, the harness of fossil fuels brought humans into the industrial revolution, productivity has skyrocketed more than ever; today, the harness of subatomic energy is going to bring human beings into a level no one has gone before. With more and more advanced technology, social system is engendered and in turn manages and determines the operation and development of technology. Basically, even though the technological system gives rise to the social system, today the social system could impose a limit upon the extent to which technology can be expanded and developed. White believes progress of civilization grows from the constant conflict between social systems and technology and will halt if both sides refuse to give in. White also argues that the future also lies in the energy situation and technological development, especially when fossil fuels are depleted. 


White’s argument is a revival of cultural revolutionism under the huge influence of Morgan and Tylor as well as a revival of comparative study against the Boasian methods. This article absorbs many former theories like Marx’s materialism to provide a more scientific and concrete model of cultural evolution. Similar to Morgan’s Unilineal Evolution model, White discusses that culture developed as humans extend control over the surrounding environment to increase food production, constantly invent and improve technology to increase efficiency, and how technological advances bring social change. However, differently, White’s model is less eurocentric and more logical by classifying culture according to ways people harness energy instead of technology and institutions “have-or-not”. He believes civilization begins with the invention of the steam engine instead of writing as Morgan claimed. One weakness in both Morgan and White’s work is that neither of them really account for the source of cultural diversity. If, as Morgan and White argued, culture evolves based on the way humans harness energy and improve technology, then how does the different way of energy expenditure and different level of technological advancement lead to cultural diversity, or even the inequality of power we have today?


Comments

Popular Posts