Critique of "The Structural Study of Myth"

 BY JACOB WRIGHT 

   In the excerpt we read from "The Structural Study of Myth", Claude Lévi-Strauss outlines a structural method for myth analysis. He employs the concept of 'mytheme': structural components of myth, similar to how phonemes are structural components of language. He argues that we should analyze myth by comparing the different types of mythemes, instead of the linear development of the myth. He organizes mythemes in the Oedipus myth into four different columns that represent different themes or types. The first two types, the overrating and underrating of blood relations, form a bilateral opposition. The second two types, the denial and affirmation of man's origins, also form a bilateral opposition. Similar to his oppositional understanding of kinship relations, Lévi-Strauss distinguishes these oppositions to show how myths have both positives and negatives. The first two categories are examples of overvaluing family (through incest and excess devotion) vs. undervaluing family (killing members of kin group). With the second two categories, Lévi-Strauss uses the phrase 'man's autochthonous origins', a reference to the Greek mythological belief that man is literally born from the ground. The second two categories highlight how humans affirm this mythic status by killing mythic monsters, but show their weak nature through their physical deficiencies.  

    For Lévi-Strauss, these two sets of mythemes form an opposition with eachother. The first two categories involve man's biological origins, while the second two involve man's mythical origins. The Greeks understood that humans are born because of biological reproduction, but they also believed that humankind's true origins had a mythic quality. Regarding the Oedipus myth, he argues that this central opposition reveals its purpose: the Oedipus myth serves to reconcile the incompatibility between these two beliefs. He thinks that myth identifies problems and presents tools to make experience fit a society's given mental structures. In this way, myth is truth because myth reveals how a society thinks about and mentally constructs the fundamental nature of reality. 

    Lévi-Strauss's methods for analyzing the Oedipus myth are questionable, as many of his conclusions seem to be mischaracterizations of the story. For example, Antigone burying her brother Polynices is categorized in the same column as Oedipus marrying his mother Jocasta. Lévi-Strauss argues that these both represent the 'overrating of blood relations', but these two events are very different and occur in unrelated contexts. His overall methods of organizing mythemes into units seems to be rigid and lacking depth/nuance. He gets bogged down by his insistence on organizing phenomena into oppositions, as this is not universally applicable. 

    Lévi-Strauss is significantly influenced by Marcel Mauss and Émile Durkheim. His theories attempt to support the idea of underlying mental constructs, similar to Durkheim's conception of collective consciousness and Mauss's concept of group mind. Lévi-Strauss departs from these earlier theorists because he does not see mental constructs as explaining social cohesion or basic social principles like reciprocity. He views mental constructs as the ways in which societies perceive themselves and the world. Essentially, mental constructs do not have a concrete social function, but provide hints into societies' big picture concepts of meaning. 

Comments

  1. Jacob:

    Firstly, your summary of The Structural Study of Myth is cogent and well synthesized. As well, I agree that his methods for analyzing the Oedipus myth is questionable and I would go even further to say that his entire idea behind mythemes seems overly prescriptive. It forces connections between different stories that probably aren’t actually there and finds meaning where it does not actually exist. For example, he posits that many integral parts of myths do not actually matter in overall analysis, such as the order of events or positive events changing into negative ones. To him any of these facets are only superficial, when it seems to me that parts of the story like the order of events or whether it has a happy or sad ending matter a great deal. For example, in Star Wars, having Mace Windu triumph over Palpatine instead of being struck down by Anakin would have tremendous impacts on the overall story and the Tragedy of Darth Vader. Changing major events in the story or when they happen completely changes the story, so obviously you can transform one myth into another if you change most of the important parts into something else. Levi-Strauss seems to be too willing to change parts of myths to fit into his classificatory scheme and imbue meaning where there is none. This is not to say that there are not general themes or recurring plot lines in stories that are separate, but I think it is much less notable than Levi-Strauss makes it out to be. A good example of this is that The Lion King is extremely similar to the plot of Shakespeare’s Hamlet, but I think this has a great deal more to do with the influence that important works have on future creations than some overlying classificatory scheme that can reduce the world’s myth to a manageable number of recurring elements.



    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mitch - you make an excellent point that important works often influence future storytelling; I had not considered this criticism.

      Delete
    2. Helpful examples pushing back against structuralist analyses of myth, Mitch!

      Delete
  2. Jacob, Thank you for this helpful and astute summary of L-S's article!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts