Critique of "The Patrilineal Band"
By Jacob Wright
In Julian Steward’s essay, “The Patrilineal Band”, he discusses how and why the patrilineal band developed. Steward describes the patrilineal band’s essential elements and practices as patrilineality (descent traced by common male ancestors), patrilocality (couples settle near husband’s family/wife lives away from her family), exogamy (marry outside of kin group), and land ownership (defined territory). The patrilineal band occurs in many cultures across a diverse array of ecological and geographical circumstances. To emphasize this point, he draws from ethnographies of groups from the barren, cold deserts of Patagonia to the remote jungles of Central Africa to the highland forests of the Malay Peninsula. Steward claims that these groups’ shared features constitute a ‘cultural core’ resembling a ‘culture type’, a distinct classification for similar cultural groups.
Steward argues that the cross-cultural similarity of patrilineal bands’ characteristics cannot be solely attributed to diffusion or cultural evolutionism. These explanations are insufficient because diffusion cannot account for the independent invention of certain technologies, hunting patterns, and kinship structures. Steward operates under the assumption that these features are the result of independent invention because many of the discussed ethnographic groups live in extreme geographic isolation from other groups and therefore were unlikely to adopt many external traits. Steward also disputes the claim that elements of the patrilineal band are what cultural evolutionist E.B. Tylor terms ‘survivals’. Survivals, leftover traits from predecessor cultures, are unlikely to be the explanation because this would have required the improbable coincidence of persistent use in a wide range of cultures over long periods of time.
Instead, Steward proposes his own model: the patrilineal band’s development can be attributed to a group’s exploitative patterns of technology and the environment. These patterns produce unique types of interactions between technology and environment that give rise to the formation of a patrilineal band. He lists four key factors that produce the patrilineal band culture type:
Low population density due to limited food resources
Principal food source of nonmigratory and scattered game
No non-human method of transportation
Kin groups that associate with one another tend to develop incest taboos requiring exogamous marriage practices
Steward outlines several examples of how these technological and environmental variables interact to produce the patrilineal band. The scattered nature of food resources lead groups to arrange themselves in small numbers in order to be able to provide enough for all members; it also forces the groups to be semi-nomadic in order to regularly find food. The nonmigratory nature of food sources means that the groups remain in a distinctly defined territory. In order to maximize the energy needed for hunting, the groups are patrilocal so that the hunters (mostly men) know the territory well. The lack of non-human transportation in the form of domesticated animals or wheeled devices, the groups are somewhat confined compared to other nomadic cultural types. Also, the low population density and infrequent interaction with other groups leads to the development of the aforementioned taboos that require exogamy.
Steward’s argument benefits from its clarity and his intriguing proposal that ecological circumstances have a direct effect on culture. Specifically, he builds off of Leslie White’s idea that different interactions with energy (which is sourced from the environment) and technology can produce distinct cultural outcomes. However, he suffers from a lack of sufficient evidence and certain failures to demonstrate clear causation between his evidence and conclusions. One of these weaknesses is that many of his cited ethnographic examples do not perfectly fit his description of patrilineal bands. For example, at least three of the nine discussed groups did not always demonstrate patrilineality and several more did not always demonstrate patrilocality. Steward does not give an explanation as to why these variations would occur or why these groups would still qualify as patrilineal bands under his definition. Further, Steward operates under the unproven assumption that the exploitative patterns and ecological circumstances lend themselves to the development of patrilineality. He does not offer any justification as to why these features would not give rise to a matrilineal culture type instead. These two omissions weaken his argument’s credibility. In addition, anthropologists of the Boasian tradition would criticize Steward’s emphasis on cross-cultural comparison because they believe that cultures should be viewed in their own individual context. Regardless, Steward’s essay contributes the important insights that (i) ecological circumstances can be a central factor in the development of culture types and (ii) anthropologists should analyze groups’ exploitative patterns to determine the origins and identity of cultural traits.
Great summary of Steward's argument which will be of much help to other readers! The PB as Steward outlines it here is an "ideal type" in the Weberian sense, so it is not surprising that there is not a perfect example of it in the real world. But as you suggest, that in and of itself calls into question the usefulness of ideal types! They are perhaps best thought of as heuristic devices we can use to think about real social situations and as vocabulary we can use to describe them (with adjustments).
ReplyDelete