Critique of "The Methods of Ethnology"
In the “The Methods of Ethnology” Franz Boas critiques dominant theoretical frameworks put forth by his European counterparts. In the text, Boas outwardly undermines the credibility of Freudian theory, cultural evolutionism, geographic determinism and diffusionism. According to Boas, the general fault of these theoretical frameworks and concepts lies in their one-dimensional and universalizing nature.
In his text, Boas draws upon two primary principles: historical particularism and cultural relativism. In my understanding, historical particularism is a notion that emphasizes each culture as continually subjected to its own distinctive or “particular” historical processes. In turn, a culture is not a static snapshot, but rather a dynamic malleable phenomenon. Boas argues, “We rather see that each cultural group has its unique history dependent partly upon the peculiar inner development of the social group, and partly upon the foreign influences to which it has been subjected” (Boas, 1920, 317). Hence, bearing its own particular history, each particular society or culture cannot possibly follow a uniform pattern of historical “progression” as the cultural evolutionists, Freud, and Marx posit.
According to my understanding, cultural relativism urges us to explore cultural phenomena (i.e. practices, values, beliefs etc.) within the context of their respective culture. As a result, Boas pushes for a movement away from eurocentric tendencies to evaluate cultural phenomena on the basis of another. Overall, the emphasis on studying culture in its context with a close attention to detail promotes a multifaceted understanding of various coinciding elements (i.e. language, history, landscape, external influences etc.) that contribute to manifestation of the cultural phenomenon in general.
Advocating for a ground-up data-driven approach instead of an overarching theoretical framework, Boas emphasizes that by focusing on the tangible and individual in the actual field, we may undermine notions of an “objective truth.” Hence, he seeks fault with concluding that a culture is a sole product of its environment. In Boas’ study of the Inuit, he concludes that while some aspects of Inuit culture can be traced to their respective environment, others are entirely unpredictable. Additionally, he counters Freud’s emphasis on psychoanalysis, emphasizing Freud’s sexual emphasis on one’s social development as highly generalized and single-faceted. He particularly calls out Freud’s neglect to consider language, which is a critical non-objective indicator of how reality is perceived and constructed (Boas, 1920, 317).
The greatest “problem” I seek with Boas’ approach lies in his neglect of archaeology, study of material remains to piece together past cultures or societies. In cases of ancient societies, excavation sites may not always have a rich archeological context filled with a variety of materials. What if you have a very limited history to work from? What if all you have seems to be products of the environment (seeds and shells for example)? According to my somewhat limited knowledge of archeology (I am more concentrated in cultural anthropology), many archaeological studies seem to function more as puzzles--you are missing elements that you have to at times assume based on a limited existing pool of knowledge. Especially in cases where you do not have ethnographic data detailing the experience of individuals within that culture, you may be lacking a clear understanding of language, actual close study of behavior, trading arrangements etc. Hence, you can’t have an immersive experience in the field so to speak. Consequently, it seems that you have to assign environment/geography a heavier weight at times.
This in mind, archaeologists aren’t necessarily encouraged to believe that all culture is a product of its environment, nor are they conditioned to believe that there is one concrete “evolutionary” model of cultural “development.” Thus, I suppose you could argue that, while Boasian theoretical framework does not outwardly mention how to consider material remains, the notion of attempting to consider more than one primary lens when analyzing remains could be somewhat “Boasian.” Thinking back to ANT 112, Dr. Jones repeatedly emphasized that archaeology requires a look into elements such as ethnographic data (if available), the consideration of looking at settlement patterns, in addition to intergroup trade based on type of materials in a respective environment, the hierarchy of a society based on burial grounds and diet. Hence, I suppose that you would still be looking closely into the field and considering all the available elements of one’s lived experience (that are available) -- both of which appear informed by Boasian anthropology.
Thanks for this nice discussion of Boas. I do think the Boasian approach, especially given the presuppositions of "salvage" anthropology, is very compatible with archaeology because the anthropologist is expected to obtain the best cultural detail possible using whatever is available. Reconstruction was very much a part of the approach. And Boas had such a rich appreciation of the cultural significance of material culture.
ReplyDelete