Critique of "Introduction to Coming of Age in Samoa"

BY MITCH BOYER


In “Introduction to Coming of Age in Samoa,” Margaret Mead seeks to explain the underlying causes of the characteristically troublesome period of development for adolescents in America through the comparison of different cultures, American and Samoan, and the social setting in which these individuals were brought up. This contrasted with the work of contemporaries like Stanley Hall, who attributed the rebellious nature of adolescents to that period of adolescent growth in general. For Hall, a rebellious teenager was as natural as a crying baby. Mead worked to dispel this notion through actual research, rather than simply drawing subjective conclusions through the seemingly omnipresent symptoms of unrest found in American adolescents. For Mead, the much more accepting and open environment (that pertained mainly to sex and responsibility) of Samoa led to those adolescents not exhibiting the same rebellious traits of American adolescents, which could be seen as reactionary to the more stifling and closed off environment of America.

         Mead is one of the most famous anthropologists ever, and she continued to build upon the American school of anthropology that was kicked off by Franz Boas. Obviously, as one of Boas’ students, Mead was influenced by his ideas of historical particularism and cultural relativism. Historical particularism can be seen in that she is interested in studying the young women from Samoa and the adolescents of America as a product of their dynamic cultural environment, rather than as a fixed, single track of evolution like a cultural evolutionist might think. Additionally, through her deep ethnographic studying of the Samoan culture, she sought to understand these individuals within the context of their culture, rather than impose European (or any other) values onto this separate system. Mead takes one step further than Boas, who did not do any comparative studies, by taking her detailed ethnographic work and comparing them to seek out how different cultural environments can shape the development of people in those societies.

         Mead was certainly a landmark figure in anthropology. Her stellar fieldwork coupled with her accessible writings popularized anthropology in a way not seen before, and not really seen since. One of her greatest assets was foregrounding the relevance of her work for western society: she made the “so what” of her work extremely apparent to her audience. She was also a comparativist, which proved to be highly effective at shedding light on the effects of cultural environments on those that lived in them, as the objective study of something as complex as American culture proves nearly impossible if left to independent study without reference to other different cultures. By comparing one culture to another, it was much easier to find similarities and differences and extrapolate information from there. However, her extreme popularity did hinder her academic impact as she was subject to a great deal of criticism throughout her career. One point of criticism was the small number of informants that she worked with. The criticism against Mead went so far that a man by the name of Derek Freeman published a book that essentially claimed that a great deal of Mead’s work was simply untrue. Whether Freeman was correct or not is another matter entirely, but just the existence of his critiques shows that many people were not convinced by Mead’s work. Regardless, Mead still lives on as one of the most important figures in anthropology, and her impacts can still be seen today. Her emphasis on the relations of personality and culture continues to be an important part of present-day anthropology and her detailed fieldwork and comparative study live on as a precedent for those conducting research in the present. While these may seem like givens to modern anthropology students, Mead was one of the pillars that first established their importance, and with her monumental contributions to the field of anthropology, there is little question as to why she is still a hallmark name in the present-day.


Comments

Popular Posts