Critique of "The Essentials of the Kula"
BY JOSH MILON
In “The Essentials of the Kula”, the third chapter of Argonauts of the Western Pacific, Bronislaw Malinowski provides an in-depth analysis of the Kula ritual practiced by the inhabitants of the islands of eastern New Guinea. Malinowski gives full descriptions of the material culture, ceremonial practices, and metaphysical components of the Kula, while ensuring to consider the perspective of the native population. Over the course of the chapter, Malinowski argues that the Kula cannot just be categorized as economic trade, and that the Kula is the keystone of these islands’ cultural structures.
The Kula is centered around the continual trading of Soulva
(necklaces) for Mwali (arm bands) between trading partners found on
the various islands of New Guinea. While this is technically a form of trading,
Malinowski emphasizes the fact that this intricate and complicated process is
far from simple economics, and it contradicts all definitions of what he refers
to as “savage trade”. Unlike the need-based “savage trade”, the Kula does not
involve an exchange of functional/ useful goods, it is not performed under the
stress of need, it is not spur of the moment, and it is highly ceremonial. In
other words, the Kula is very precisely structured, and there are several
distinct rules that must be followed when people participate in the ritual. For
starters, not everyone in a community can participate in the Kula, and transactions
can only be done between partners. These partners have a number of mutual
duties to one another, such as exchanging gifts and services, and they are
bound for life. For the trading itself, armbands can only be traded for necklaces
and vice versa. This rule creates two circular trade routes for the objects
around the various islands of eastern New Guinea: with necklaces moving clockwise,
and armbands moving counterclockwise. Lastly, no individual is allowed to hold onto
one of these items indefinitely. The maximum amount of time a person can keep a
Soulva or Mwali is about one to two years, and then they must trade them for an
armband or necklace respectively.
It is also important to note here that there are several
secondary activities and rituals that occur around the Kula. These include rituals
to protect canoes from harmful magic, magic rituals to ensure that a village will
have successful trades, and “secondary trade” in which Kula sailors trade
natural resources from their island to trade for the natural resources of
another.
Malinowski argued that the main purposes of the Kula were to
build prestige and status, and to create and maintain relationships between intra
and interisland villages. Malinowski saw status and prestige manifested in the
Kula system in two ways. First, the number of trading partners an individual
has is based on their hierarchical status. While a commoner may only have a few
partners, a chief would have several hundred. Second, extremely valuable Soulva
and Mwali could only pass through chiefs, and when a chief obtained one of
these coveted items, their ownership of the piece (while short lived) would be
recorded in the Soulva’s or Mwali’s history, thus increasing the chief’s
prestige. Malinowski proposed the idea that this system of building prestige
through ownership was based on the innate human nature of “historic sentimentalism”
where objects with historical connotations that are passed down through
historic peoples automatically have great value.
Malinowski was one of the two most venerated figures in British
Social Anthropology and was the first and foremost practitioner of participant
observation, in which anthropologists would live among the people they were
studying in order to understand the culture from a native perspective. The other
key contributor to British Social Anthropology was A.R. Radcliffe-Brown. While
both anthropologists worked in a synchronic framework, (focusing on how things
function in a given moment rather than over time) Radcliffe-Brown was more concerned
with social systems and their structures, while Malinowski was a psychological
functionalist, and was concerned with the needs of individuals and their roles
in creating social systems. Also, Radcliffe-Brown was a proponent of the “organic
analogy” in which society is compared to an organism. Malinowski, on the other
hand, related actual biology to his anthropological studies, and placed an
emphasis on how human biological needs are met with basic responses, which then
create cultural needs that are satisfied by cultural responses, thus creating
social structures.
Malinowski’s “The Essentials of the Kula” still holds up to
modern standards, and its greatest strength is the consistent use of
participant observation. Malinowski’s introduction of this practice was ground-breaking
at the time and is still widely used by anthropologists today. The main limitation
of this paper is that he does not account for change in culture over time. With
a synchronic approach, Malinowski’s study of the Kula ignores the history of
the ritual’s development. With out some level of understanding of the past, it
is impossible to obtain a whole image of a system in the present. Also, looking
at the Kula in a single moment removes the possibility of seeing any change in
the system, as well as the reasons for those changes.
Although the Kula doesn't serve to meet basic needs, shouldn't it be connectible to basic needs in some way given Malinowski's functionalist approach?
ReplyDelete