Critique of "The Cultural Ecology of India's Sacred Cattle"
Meilyn Norman
—
"The Cultural Ecology of India's Sacred Cattle" is a paper by Marvin Harris (1927-2001). It discusses the social stigma against slaughter of cows in India, something that many Westerners do not understand. If so many people are hungry, why are the cattle allowed to starve, rather than being eaten? Harris attributes the 'overabundance' of cattle to economic and societal structures, saying that there are perfectly logical explanations for the seemingly excess cattle. He explains that the cattle are worth more alive than dead because of the multiple functions they provide, primarily physical labor through plowing, but also dung as fertilizer and milk. Furthermore, the cattle are sometimes eaten in times of need, such as WWII or by underprivileged members of society. They also are relatively inexpensive to keep since they are mainly pasture-fed and do not directly compete with humans for resources. Therefore, the cattle’s economic function is the real reason that they are not killed and eaten, rather than the cultural taboo.
This paper is contextualized within the larger school of “cultural materialism,” founded by Harris, that situates cultural study within either the emic or etic perspective and the behavioral and mental domain. In doing so, he defines emic/etic as the native/outside perspective. He divides the behavioral, what people actually do, and the mental, the reasons why they do things. He claims that the emic behavioral perspective is problematic because people can misunderstand their own behavior. The etic mental perspective is also problematic because one cannot know what another’s motivation is. Harris himself advocated for the etic behavioral perspective, which allows human culture to be observed and studied scientifically. He is clearly influenced by Marx because of his focus on the material. He claims that material culture (modes of production and reproduction, which he calls infrastructure) is the first level of culture and the easiest to change. He goes on to describe the second layer, structure (which describes the social structures, such as economy or politics) and the third, superstructure (which is based in symbols and ideas). Harris believed that each level drives the next. Thus, his focus on means of production as a cultural determiner is similar to that of dialectical materialism, even if he criticizes Marx for excluding the mode of reproduction. Within American anthropology, he situated himself as a critic of Boas, whose work he found nonscientific and non-rigorous. He thought that human cultures should be studied from an outside perspective because it would be more objective. Finally, I would argue that we can see the echoes of Evans-Pritchard within “The Cultural Ecology...Cattle” specifically because he argues that behavior seen to Western societies as irrational—“wasting” the cows’ economic potential because of religious beliefs—was actually rational to those who actually lived in the society.
Due to his acknowledgement of native reason, Harris manages to be somewhat relativist. He challenges Western assumptions of the correct use of the cattle. He argues in defense of Indian people, saying that their actions do actually make sense. He writes in ways that Western audiences can understand. However, my major criticism of him is that his work is not nearly relativist enough. His argument for the cattle still relies on Western economics, rather than an insider perspective. Harris’ dismissal of religious and moral reasons to not eat the cattle is problematic because he contradicts himself by assuming an etic mental position. He says that not eating cattle is actually an economic, rather than spiritual decision. However, he cannot know the true motivations of the population that he is studying. In the beginning of the paper, he confesses that he has not conducted any fieldwork in India; he has not even visited. Therefore, he relies on the secondhand accounts of other people to make his case. In my opinion, this paper is entirely too reliant on a conglomeration of quotes and “data points” collected by other people. Harris’ argument is not original; he synthesizes other people’s arguments, but they also claim that the cows have a great economic importance.
Based on Harris’ lack of experience in Indian fieldwork, his entire argument may be invalidated. It is entirely possible that the population chooses not to eat the cows for religious reasons, and the economic structure has been built upon the lack of beef as a food source. I am not saying that this is necessarily true, but I think it is potentially true. Therefore, not only is Harris’ argument reversed, but also his universal pattern—infrastructure, structure, and superstructure—are also flipped because it is the beliefs of a people that are impacting their economic structure. Not only that, but his work seems to be too deterministic. He understands the ways that environment invariably impacts the practices of individuals, but he barely acknowledges the cultural beliefs of the society. However, I believe that the creativity and individuality of cultures, including India and the ‘sacred cow’, have more than purely materialist origins.
Overall, I think that Harris makes some excellent points regarding the study of other cultures by starting at the material level to explain beliefs that we may think are ‘irrational.’ His ability to synthesize large swaths of information to make a cohesive argument about the role of eating cattle is valuable, and I truly believe that the study of structures can help illuminate the struggles of different parts of a society. However, his work is too deterministic, and in attempting to be scientific and objective, he is dismissive of cultural values and intentions.
Very nice post; I'm sure it will be helpful to the class!
ReplyDelete