Critique of "The Cultural Ecology of India's Sacred Cattle"
Harris then moves to discuss the treatment of the animals, especially the difference between cattle that are considered useful versus cattle that are considered useless, making clear that killing animals for economic efficiency is done in India, but only through neglect and progressive starvation so as not to be directly responsible for the death of a scared animal.
Harris concludes his findings by claiming that the actual relationship between humans and cattle in India is symbiotic, and that given the economic and technological state of the nation, large numbers of cattle are in fact necessary to continue to sustain the human population. However he concedes that more energy-efficient ways of sustaining India’s population can be created.
The main limitation I thought of in this study was the disconsideration of the system as a religious one - the study’s conclusion indicates that India may be able to create some more efficient system, but it does not verbalize HOW this may be done without violating the religious creed. They can’t effectively sell the cows, as many of their cows are smaller or yield less than cows of other nations, and they cannot kill them. They could starve the cows as they implement the new system, but this would create a huge number of dead cows and would imply that the economy of India would either be able to deal with a large number of dead cows when they already don’t have enough working, or that they could effectively afford and implement this system while their economy has not significantly changed. Harris’ functionalist perspective also ignores socio-cultural implications and impacts of having a strict adherence to the ahimsa law, which likely has an important impact on the entire nation.
I would argue that this piece is overall a well thought-out example of an analysis of a phenomenon which has widely been reduced to a general thought - ‘religious doctrine has created an energy inefficiency in India’ - but in reality is more complex. We should apply this line of thinking to other anthropological theories in the future, as should all members of the scientific community in their fields.
Comments
Post a Comment