Critique of Conklin's “Hanunóo Color Categories’”

 CHRISTIAN ESTRADA


    We can all remember the cultural phenomenon of the 2015 Dress debate. Was it blue with black stripes? White with gold stripes?  Or do you, like me, believe that it just depends on the brightness of your device’s screen? This heated debate occurred only within the frameworks or our westernized color terminology. Still, if it were to make its way to the Mangaryun Islands where  Hanunoo is spoken, we would have seen a very different set of answers. Conklin, a well-known ethnoscientist, used his research of the Hanunoo color categories to explain that the world around us does, in fact, have an impact on the language in which we formulate and speak. Rather than Sapir and Whorf’s hypothesis, which suggested one’s language shapes their views of the world around them. 


    One could say his main message of the article, besides debunking Saphi-Whorf’s argument, was to ensure that the field of anthropology would no longer impose our linguistic understanding of color onto the cultures we study. Once Conklin made that point very clear, he branched into his research on uncovering the various categorical differences and similarities between how either the Hanunoo or our western colors were created. He then formulated a 2 level classification system that would help bridge the gap between the two ways of categorizing color. Level 1 was less specific and explained colors based on the relative lightness, darkness, and presence of green or red. Then Level 2 was explained if level 1 failed, and it included shades or texture. Some colors are tied to cultural cues within both categories, like more brightly colors being more valuable than natural earth tones. 


    Overall, Conklin’s argument is well organized. Even though there were many technical terms within his article that some may not be familiar with, his message is still clearly presented. While its only weakness was the number of technical terms within his argument, I don’t necessarily understand it fully and can’t easily verify the correlations. 


    But anywho, I learned that even though there are a vast amount of cultural differences with any and everything from clothes, beliefs, and perceptions, there are still some fundamental traits of color perception that can be connected across culture. 


    Therefore if we were to resurface the 2015 dress debate and present those of the Mangaryan Islands with the heated question. We will learn to leave our “western colors” at the door and accept the answer option of either “mabiru” which includes black, violet, indigo,” and “malagti,” which includes “white and very light tints of other colors” in combination with their word for gold,  “bulawan.”


                                                                - ChristianEstrada99


Comments

  1. Sorry! Just realized the word count says minimum of 400 words not 400 words max!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts