CRITIQUE AND MODERN APPLICATION OF MAUSS'S THE GIFT
CRITIQUE AND MODERN APPLICATION OF MAUSS'S THE GIFT
In the book The Gift, Marcel Mauss analyzes the nature of exchange and its obligations. A prime aspect of Mauss's argument is that social organizations are reasonably consistent between individuals. Potlatches are Mauss's primary mechanism to explain this social organization.
Mauss uses the Tsimshian myth to describe the importance of distributing goods from a potlach and the obligation it comes with. In the myth, "the institutional fabric…the potlatch – the distribution of goods – is the fundamental act of public recognition in all spheres" (pg. 99). This phenomenon's power is that it is more than just a legal transaction based on objections and self-interest; Mauss describes it as "one of those phenomena we propose to call 'total'" (pg. 98). The potlatch concerns individual and collective rights; it's political because it's of the interest of the clans, families, and classes, religious because it is the diffusion of a mentality, and chiefs take part are incarcerations of gods and ancestors. The transactions have economic notions of utility and function. Value, wealth, and accumulation are continually present because each time there is an exchange, these are the important aspects. Finally, it is a morphological phenomenon because it happens in the course of gatherings and acts as a reunion for tribes, clans, and families. Arguably this is what gives the process so much authority and validity.
Overall, this process of exchange creates relationships and obligations that act as social glue. Because the gifts cannot be refused and must be repaid, exchanges represent a concrete practice that embodies and creates social solidarity. They receive gifts are always accepted and praised; failure to do so means a loss of dignity for your family and those associated with you. Repaying the gift is the essence of the potlatch and the function that facilitates the social glue. A weakness of Mauss is that when the scope of the social organization increases to state-level or even international, this paradigm is not the same because the system of obligation (sometimes) varies on social relationships. While all of these byproducts of the ceremonial potlatch provide excellent social obligation frameworks and cohesion, its application to a modern world is not as neat.
Elements of this exchange system are present today, however, to a very different degree. Gifts given for significant life events like a wedding, baby shower, birthday, or engagement are ceremonial in practice and adhere to social norms. Still, there is no guarantee (or even obligation) that the gift will be repaid. Giving the gifts in these cases is individualized and represents an event occurring in another person's life and your relationship with that person. Whereas in the Potlach's, the gifts are given to people around you to show off your own wealth and prosperity. For instance, person A gets married, and person B gives an expensive wedding gift to person A; that gift (or the gift's value) might not ever be repaid if person B doesn't get married. In this situation, the exchange and obligation are situated in a different social norm; the norm here to give person A something for their "special day," but if person B never has a special day, person A will not repay it aspect.
Comments
Post a Comment