Critique and Discussion: "The Apotheosis of Captain Cook"


Critique and Discussion: "The Apotheosis of Captain Cook"

By: Jack Talton


In “The Apotheosis of Captain Cook” by Marshall Sahlins there is a good argument that Captain Cook was seen as a god we can look several pieces of evidence that Sahlins gives us such as an account of one of the men who came originally from his ship which says "The fact was that I (as well as many others) had been so used to look up to him [Captain Cook] as our good genius, our safe conductor, and as a kind of superior being, that I could not suffer myself, I did not dare, to think he could fall by the hands of Indians”. This statement shows that even men from his ship after seeing the interactions between Cook and the Hawaiian natives  they themselves were beginning to see him as an elevated human being. The most convincing piece of evidence from this article, is that the Hawaiian natives, to determine if he was a god killed Captain Cook and even after they had killed him and knew that he was dead, continued to wait for his return for a long time to come, and as Sahlins states frequently, the natives saw Captain Cook as a superior being. 

Sahlins does explain and here is an argument that Hawaiian natives believed that Captain James Cook was a god which I talked about briefly in the previous paragraph, he also looks at the Hawaiian beliefs in reference to deity figures as well as somewhat of a parallel with European thought at the time, which is something, I found interesting. In the first several pages of the article Sahlins speaks about how Hawaiians first believed in god’s of nature that controlled the sun and moon, all-natural phenomena. As this progressed, these natural phenomena became human as individual men came to power and these high chiefs became these god-like figures. Many of them were not eternal and didn’t live forever and oftentimes like what happened in the situation of Captain James Cook were killed, not because those following them or subordinate to them were unhappy or disliked them, but because they wanted to know if they truly were gods, because if they were then they would rise from the dead and come back to life, which I thought was weirdly close to the common beliefs held in Christianity in reference to Jesus Christ and his resurrection. However, before being killed these chiefs were looked at and believed to be gods and as mentioned by Sahlins this paralleled some European thoughts of the time such as “The Divine Right of Kings”. The Divine Right of Kings is the belief that a monarch or individual ruler was given this position and authority by god to rule people, and this power was absolute until the people felt like he was going in the wrong direction or were outraged by something they did and somehow lost this authority and in turn losing their divinity. In comparison to this, in Hawaii they would kill the leader as if to prove they were gods, as I mentioned earlier in this paragraph. So it is interesting to see, as we have two civilizations who advanced, for the most part, separately, had a similar belief and stage of  “religious”/ ”spiritual” development. 


Source: "The Apotheosis of Captain Cook" by Marshall Sahlins

 

I’m sure you have all heard of the divine right of kings, but JSTOR daily had an article that I found interesting so the link to that article is here: 

 

 

https://daily.jstor.org/making-sense-of-the-divine-right-of-kings/

Comments

Popular Posts