A Critique of "What Is a Social Fact?"
Within Émile Durkheim’s essay, “What Is A Social Fact?”, he explained how certain aspects of social life, such as expectations or values have coercive power on people to act, think, and feel a certain way. These, he termed, are social facts. He described how social facts are external from any individual manifestations and argued that individuals did not create society but instead simply were born into a world with preexisting morals and expectations. For example, he explained how some forms of social organization, like the system of currency we use or the laws that our society imposes on us are functions independent from any one individual. These aspects constrain people to follow them. If someone attempts to rebel against these social facts, they could provoke ridicule or social isolation upon themselves. Attempts at escaping social facts, he claims, often fail because it is almost impossible to function within society without adhering to fundamental social facts.
One very interesting concept of a social fact that Durkheim described is that of early childhood and education. As soon as a child is born, they are taught by their parents how to function properly within society. Education imposes upon children how to see, feel, and act. In this way, Durkheim explained that education was aimed at the socialization of human beings. In this way, parents and teachers are the mediators for applying social facts upon children from a young age.
Durkheim also stated stating how social facts can affect an individual even if they are not in a crystallized form, such as various social organizations. These are called social currents. These social currents often affect an individual’s emotions or attitudes when in a large crowd, to the point where it may force them to think or act differently from what is natural to them. This can also cause acts of atrocity in some circumstances, even if the participants are all individually harmless normally. Thus, the experience they have when feeding off of a common emotion in a crowd would be starkly different from the feeling they would have had alone in the same situation. Even if someone tried to go against this group behavior, the collective manifestations of the group would consequently turn against them. This relates to the notion of “group mind”, or “collective conscious”. This refers to shared beliefs, values, or symbols of members within the same culture that affect the actions of those individuals. The collective conscious binds members of society together and subsequently helps to regulate society.
Some of Durkheim’s concepts, such as the example with early childhood development and education, display similarities with that of Sigmund Freud. Freud’s depiction of the different psychosexual stages of childhood development seems to really complement Durkheim’s description of children going through stages of understanding acceptable societal norms. Durkheim also explained how Herbert Spencer had created a process that related to his concept of childhood socialization. This is where Spencer claimed a rational education would reject methods for socialization and instead allow a child to act with complete freedom. Durkheim also influenced numerous anthropologists with his work, such as Marcell Mauss, who used Durkheim’s concept of social facts to understand the structure of social cohesion. Other structural-anthropologists like A.R. Radcliffe-Brown, were influenced by Durkheim’s work. Radcliffe-Brown used the concept of social facts and believed that they needed to be understood within their own terms of social laws.
Durkheim made some very strong assertions within his work, such as how there are societal expectations that bare down on people, to the point where people feel obliged to follow them or else risk social repercussions. Also, it makes a lot of sense how school and our early childhood were ways to help prep us for being able to interact and function properly in the real world with other people. However, a critique of Durkheim would be that he focused much of his work on the mind of the group and did not pay as much attention to the autonomy of individual people and their personalities/emotions. Even in his essay, he explained how average annual suicides, births, and marriages are all part of the group mind. This formulation does not account of individual cases or circumstances for these social phenomena. Instead, it attributes these things as being part of a wider societal conscious that drives these occurrences.
Jarrett, as always your critique is written very well. I think you did a great job of analyzing and understanding the work of Durkheim and even though I read and looked at the work or Durkheim It hasn't all clicked until now. From the beginning I think I just observed the work of Durkheim as being to "blanket" like because of his ideas of sui genesis and his lack of focus on the autonomy of the individuals. I definitely didn't like the lack of attention for emotions and how everything was tied into like a singular group mind. I felt this way because I felt it robs the point of view of the minority (not just in race but in almost every facet of society). And within societies where there is already little attention paid to those left behind I felt the group mind aspect just added to recluisivity. However, the way you explained Durkhiems idea of the collective conscious I realized that I don't necessarily disagree with his idea because it makes a lot of sense. I just didn't like the truth of the situation. Sadly, our "group mind" has contributed to the suffering and oppression of individuals for centuries in multiple ways and our westernized group mind has infiltrated other cultures collective conscious. So now i'm just left to wonder if there is a chance to ever change the group mind? But I guess we will just have to wait until a generations seizes to distribute the toxic thinking of the past.
ReplyDelete