Critiques of Ethnical Periods and Cultural Evolutionism

    In Lewis H. Morgan’s Ethnical Periods, he outlines what he sees to be the three stages or steps of cultural evolution. Much of Morgan’s ideas are based on a teleology viewpoint. This line of theory implies that all societies have and will follow a certain trajectory, a simple way of understanding the differences between cultures and cultural stages. To cultural evolutionists, history is not random. The idea that there are stages in human history is put forth by E.B. Taylor and is known as psychic unity, which is the doctrine that all people have the same fundamental capacity for change. Psychic unity helps provide a foundation for cultural evolutionism because it implies that all humans have the same ability to reach a certain level of social structure. This line of theory also implied that change was imminent and a positive, natural progression. 

    Cultural evolutionism serves as an explanation of culture in terms of the purpose it serves rather than of causes of culture. There are various categories or elements of society that make up each stage. The seven elements that Morgan identifies are subsistence, government, language, the family, religion, house life/architecture, and property. From these seven categories, he develops Ethnical periods that show society’s progression from a more primitive to advanced form. The first is savagery. In this stage, there is the beginning cultivation of fire, and the stage ends with the relative invention of pottery.  Barbarism is the second, which is characterized by the invention of pottery. As this period progresses, the domestication of animals and new irrigation systems is created along with the eventual manufacturing of iron and a phonetic alphabet’s development. This period marked the beginning of a new period with human affairs of material. The final period is civilization which language is the true hallmark of. These stages are heavily reliant on the basis of sex, then kinship, and finally territory, as like most of this theory the three factors of consideration are from a western context. Morgan only acknowledges sex and kinship as he understands and fails to account for a different view. 

    The theory of cultural evolutionism attempts to put a very complex network of countries and cultures into one pretty box that does not allow for variation or deviation. It uses several key ‘developments’ as markers of cultural success; those ‘developments’ are essential to society’s progression; however, I would argue these are not the only ones. Explaining culture through a linear progression of three key characteristics fails to account for other ‘developments’. One example of a counter to Morgan’s theory was Ruth Benedict, who rejected cultural evolutionism on the basis that there is not one culture but rather cultures. Benedict said that all cultures have a personality configuration.


Comments

  1. Helpful thoughts about Morgan. Interestingly, you seem to simultaneously accept and reject the evolutionary framework. What are the additional markers of "progress" that you think Morgan leaves out, and how do you define "progress"? When you say that "language" is the ultimate marker of "civilization," do you mean literacy?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello, (I don't see your name sorry), I personally think you did a good job getting into the head of Morgan and gave some good explanations of cultural evolution. And I'm sure we both agree that the idea of cultural evolutionism is outdated and ethnocentric, like most of the theories of the earlier thinkers. However, I saw that you mentioned you would "argue these are not the only ones" and that Morgan's three stages don't include other "developments" and I feel that suggests that you sort of agree with the comparative method, which I'm sure you don't. So similarly to Dr. Bender's comment, it seems that you accept and reject Morgan's argument. However, like I said I'm sure you don't but I think another thing that really separated Boas and Mead from the earlier thinkers, like Morgan, is that they rejected the comparative method and focused more on in-depth ethnographic fieldwork. And from that data, they were able to also show that the "linear progression" that you mentioned was not innately biological with universal characteristics that would place them into the three categories. Instead, the unique and raw differences of culture lead to the differences within various societies. And that was depicted through Mead's work you mention and then also Boas's with the Inuit tribes. In addition, I also agree that Morgan's framework is too general and tries to place the reason of the adaptations of culture into a little box. I also think since he was early to the game with his theory he just wanted to try and answer all of the question with his single answer and as we can see it doesn't work that easy.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts