Critique of Civilization and Its Discontents
BY ALLY SWARTZBERG
In his work Civilization and Its Discontents, Freud considers the increasingly popular hostility toward civilization as the source of human misery, a position suggesting that the way back to happiness is movement back to a more primitive state of society. Freud wrote this work in Germany following the first WWI -- a period which highlighted the pessimistic side of civilization as a conflict ridden space. He brings to the forefront the perception of “foreign” races as living a happier, simpler life, and in so doing, draws attention to the ethnocentrism of his time. A critical question outlined in this work is whether “civilization” -- that is, the cultural evolutionary pinnacle of social structures -- provides a viable means of achieving happiness.
In order to consider civilization’s limitations, Freud defines its nature as “the whole sum of the achievements and regulations which distinguish our lives from those of our animal ancestors...” Such a view of civilization seems built upon utility, with culture defined as the culmination of activities which assist in making the earth serviceable to humans. But there is also a “useless” part of civilization consisting of beauty, cleanliness, and order. These non-utility functions of society do not sustain life, and yet they are critical. This suggests that the motive forces of human behavior, utility and pleasure, counterbalance each other through some regulatory process. Here, Freud begins to draw parallels between the individual human psyche and the culture of civilization.
The id is responsible for primal urges while the superego features a morality or conscience that restricts urges. The ego attempts to balance the two by mediating urge and restriction. Freud extrapolates this regulation of the psyche and applies it to society, suggesting that civilization imposes control to restrict primal urges, but also redirects primal urges into a free expression of will through a process of sublimation. Here, he claims that culturally unacceptable urges are repurposed, allowing the urge to be satisfied in a manner that is culturally acceptable -- balancing utility and pleasure, urge and conscience.
Freud’s work is foundational to any further understanding of social science. Yet, I find flaws in his overextension of this finding. The parallels between id, ego, and superego and the relationship between freedom and social order are significant, and I would contend that enculturation into normative behavior allows for a form of sublimation wherein every member of a culture learns how to express urges in a manner that is deemed acceptable. But this process does not only exist in “civilized” societies, and the concept of civilization as the mechanism of cultural regulation is flawed. The idea that Western civilization is required for a process of enculturation and normative sublimation to occur within a populous is a flawed outgrowth of the cultural evolutionary perspective which places European society at the top of global cultural hierarchy.
So, can civilization provide a viable means of achieving happiness? Perhaps, through sublimating urges toward a culturally acceptable outcome, one could argue that the individual actor still satisfies their urge. A more important question for our time may be whether civilization, as it is defined here, is a worthy goal in itself, or if it is simply one of many valuable social structures that exists globally. From here, it is also worth considering whether civilization is the social embodiment of ego, or can any process of enculturation act as that mediating force between urge and conscience.
Nice discussion of Freud! Is it possible to adapt his theory so that it is a theory of all bureaucratized, highly-regulated societies, rather than just one of "Western Civilization"? If so, would you then agree with his premise?
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteI don't know that my issue with Freud would dissipate entirely if the theory were adapted -- though it would certainly alleviate this particular issue. What was difficult to get across in a post of this length was the continued issue of "over breadth" I find within this piece. That is, the relationship between freedom and social order does not, in my view, adequately explain all human behavior. The assertion that all adult human behavior is the result of some developmental fixation feels like a stretch. I chose not to focus on that here because I believe most people in the class agree that this is a stretch, and I wanted to call to the forefront an additional point of concern.
DeleteI can't edit in a byline but I wrote this entry
ReplyDelete