Applying Kroeber to Contemporary Media Trends
In Alfred Kroeber’s On the Principle of Order in Civilization as Exemplified by Changes in Fashion, he claims that individuals do not drive culture. Instead, individuals operate within the cultural circumstances of the time. This model of culture as enabling individual success can be applied to contemporary trends in entertainment media. For example, the pandemic had a direct effect on video consumption. During lockdowns, people watched significantly more television as a result of being stuck at home. As kids activities were canceled and schools closed, families bought subscriptions to streaming services like Disney Plus and Netflix to occupy their children. Popularity of programs like Tiger King has often been attributed to this increased viewership pool. Kroeber would view the success of Tiger King and the subscriber growth of streaming services as reflections of the contemporary cultural landscape, not as examples of creative achievement or business genius.
In his discussion of fashion trends, Kroeber discusses phenomena such as the invention of the Grecian Bend in 1872. He claims that this ‘swing of fashion’ should be looked upon as a product of preceding dress styles or of other cultural factors. These factors are more important and relevant to understanding fashion trends than the talent or creativity of individuals. The breakout success of the musical Hamilton and the recently released TV drama Bridgerton provide great contemporary examples for comparison. Premiered in 2015, Hamilton received widespread acclaim and quickly acquired a large popular following. While Kroeber might have applauded the musical’s acting and writing, he would have pointed to other explanations for its success. For example, the show combines patriotic storytelling with popular contemporary music styles and inclusive casting. Kroeber would most likely point to these characteristics to show how Hamilton perfectly fit the cultural moment of its time. Released amid the 2016 American elections – a period characterized by hate, fear, and mistrust – the musical championed a welcoming, multicultural understanding of patriotism and the American Dream.
Released five years later, Bridgerton experienced a similar reception to Hamilton. While there are many differences between the two shows, Kroeber would maybe have a narrow understanding of the British program’s popularity. He would most likely view Bridgerton as a product of both its predecessor Hamilton and of its own cultural moment. In his view, Bridgerton would have mirrored the successes of Hamilton because of the similar inclusive casting and innovative uses of contemporary music. Further, Bridgerton’s release came during a time of increased public discourse about race and gender, especially in popular media. Kroeber may have also pointed to the pandemic as another factor to consider in evaluating the show’s popularity.
Nice discussion of the limitations of the "superorganic" as a concept!
ReplyDeleteJust wanted to add that if you stand back and take a more distant view of Hamilton and Bridgerton, they do reflect larger cultural trends toward the acknowledgment of intersectionality, toward integrating a critique of race into popular culture, etc. It's probably not taking anything away from their creators to say that they could not, would not, have been produced a generation earlier. So (as I think you are probably suggesting) we might want to acknowledge both the praxis of individuals and the material and cultural circumstances through and with which they engage in that praxis.
Delete