A Critique of "On Joking Relationships"
In A.R. Radcliffe-Brown's essay, "On Joking Relationships", he described the social dynamics that play a role in the "joking relationship" amongst members of a lineage/kinship or between differing tribes. Essentially, a joking relationship is typically where two people are allowed to pick on or make fun of one another. The person who is being made fun of is therefore not allowed to take offense to the joking, as it is a societal custom. Basically, it is societally permitted for one person to disrespect the other yet can still be seen as friendly banter. This relationship comes in numerous forms, however, one of the more well-known concepts is joking with people of your own generation or lower. Normally, a sense of respect due to seniority is present amongst joking relationships. For example, a wife's parents or older siblings are typically not picked on by the wife's husband, however, her younger siblings could be fair game. The opposite of a joking relationship is what's called "avoidance". This can be where a spouse will often times avoid their parents-in-law as a sign of respect and to avoid any conflicts or social disjunctions.
Another, more rare form of a joking relationship is between two tribes, as can be seen between African tribes such as the Zaramu and Sukuma. These relations are often for the purpose of alliance through trade and exchange. The show of hostility and mutual disrespect helps to establish a form of friendship between outsiders who are not inherently linked through intermarriage.
This evidence only furthers the argument that Radcliffe-Brown poses; a joking relationship is a unique form of alliance either between members of a kinship or between tribes. These alliances are built through mutual disrespect yet provide goods and services. Although a joking relationship does not have to exist in order for this type of alliance to be formed, it helps create a social conjunction that allows for different members to assist one another, either through gifts or trade. This ties into Radcliffe-Brown's theory that joking relationships combine alliances amongst tribes as well as between relatives in order to organize a stable system of social behavior that can effectively be maintained.
Much of Radcliffe-Browns theories were influenced by Durkheim's concepts of mechanical and organic solidarity. These concepts eventually helped transform his theoretical research of how various customs and social institutions help maintain a balanced social structure amongst non-Western societies. Also, like Durkheim, he believed that social facts could only be explained in terms of social structures, and not through individual psychology. His theories influenced multiple disciples, such as E.E. Evans-Pritchard. Radcliffe-Brown's theories of social structure influenced Evans-Pritchard's explanation for how some East African hierarchical societies could efficiently function without overt leadership involved.
Radcliffe-Brown makes some very compelling arguments in his examination of joking relationships and social structure. Some of his strengths would be that he tried to use a scientific justification for unwritten social laws/practices amongst various societies in not only North America, but Africa, Asia and Oceania as well. His theories help to explain how potential conflict amongst relatives or tribes can be effectively avoided through either joking or avoidance. However, at times Radcliffe-Brown tried to generalize various forms of joking relationships to societies that may not incorporate that specific relational structure. This could be because Radcliffe-Brown focused much of his research efforts on theories and less on fieldwork. It seems as though he tried to make universal principles for joking relationships and social systems instead of going through a case by case basis. He also tended to claim that joking is a concept independent from an individual's personality and has more to do with the social system as a whole. This seems to minimize the importance of an individual's autonomy and personality.
Very nice synthesis; I am sure it will be helpful to your classmates as they prepare for the midterm!
ReplyDelete